When it comes to carpet cleaners, two of the very best manufacturers on the market are Bissell and Rug Doctor. Both of these manufacturers have put together some fantastic carpet cleaners.

Many people are uncertain of where to start with these two manufacturers, and many people are unaware of what the best carpet cleaner, from either of these brands, actually is. This can make the buying process a little confusing and uncertain. And that is why we’ve put together this buying guide.

Rug Doctor Deep vs Bissell Big Green

In this buying guide, we’re going to be looking at two excellent carpet cleaners; one from Bissell, and one from Rug Doctor.

To start, we’ll be looking at the Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner Machine. After that, we’ll be looking at the Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner. By the time you are finished reading this guide, you are going to know which one of these carpet cleaners is the very best one for you.

One thing to remember, though, is that these carpet cleaners are quite advanced, and this means that they’re a bit more expensive than some of the others on the market. So, make sure to keep that in mind.

Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner Machine Review

Right off the bat, we’re going to start with the Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner Machine 86T3! This is a very advanced carpet cleaner, and the price does reflect that. With that being said, though, you are paying for quality, and this carpet cleaner is very much the epitome of “quality”.

Bissell Big Green vs. Rug Doctor Deep

If you take a look at the design, you’ll notice that it resembles a lawn mower, in many ways. The design is somewhat bulky and cumbersome, and it is quite wide. This is because it is quite powerful, and needs a way to contain that power, and so that the cleaning path is large enough to make the cleaning process quick and speedy.

On the bottom of the carpet cleaner, there is something known as the “Extra-Large DirtLifter PowerBrush”. This particular device is a very large brush, which consists of many smaller brushes embedded within it, and this brush is incredibly powerful. While you are moving the Bissell Big Green across your carpet, this brush is being used to brush up all of the dirt, dust, and debris that is in its path. But, due to the strength and depth of the individual brushes that comprise this single brush, it’s able to remove the dirt and grime that has been submerged within the folds of your carpet.

Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner Machine 86T3

As this process is unfolding, the Bissell Big Green produces a significant amount of suction, and this suction is used to remove the dirt, dust, and general grime that is getting brushed up. This ensures that nothing gets stuck on the brushes and that everything on the carpet gets properly disposed of. Without this suction, that process would be significantly more challenging.

Working in conjunction with the suction and the brushes, water is being sprayed onto your carpet. This water is sprayed lightly, and from this spraying, it allows more of the dirt and grime to be removed. On the carpet cleaner itself, there are two tanks. One of these tanks is used for clean water, and the other tank is used to hold the dirty water. Due to this system, it’s much easier to keep the tanks clean.

Ultimately, the Bissell 86T3 Big Green is one of the best and most powerful carpet cleaners on the market. If you want power and efficiency, this is an excellent choice!

Bissell Big Green Review

Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner Review

Next up, we have the Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner. Now, this is a carpet cleaner that is much less expensive than the Bissell Big Green, and it’s also a bit less powerful. But, it’s not that much different, in the end, and the Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner has some excellent features.

On the bottom of this carpet cleaner, there are small sets of brushes. These aren’t huge brushes, but there are a lot of individual brushes and bristles, which does make the carpet cleaning process very quick, and effective. As these brushes move around, they pick up all kinds of dirt and debris, and then, using the powerful suction that this carpet cleaner produces, it’s sucked into the carpet cleaner.

Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner; Upright Portable Deep Cleaning Machine

All of this is done effectively, and, overall, this is an excellent carpet cleaner. You won’t have any issues when it comes to the cleaning ability and general effectiveness of the Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner.

Here’s the thing, though, while this is a great carpet cleaner, in that aspect, one of the things that make it stand out is the fact that the Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner has a very simple and effortless design that makes it incredibly easy to use.

There’s a nice handle, and the wheels work well on all kinds of carpeting, as well as other surfaces, and then you have a tank that is super easy to lift so that you can dump it out and then clean it. And then, once you’ve cleaned your carpet and you don’t need to use it anymore, you can push the handle down, and the carpet cleaner folds into itself. From this, you can store it just about anywhere, since it doesn’t take up that much space.

Ultimately, if you want a carpet cleaner that isn’t too expensive, but very effective, and with a simple and sleek design that is simply the epitome of convenience, then the Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner is a fantastic choice!

Rug Doctor Deep Review


Of the two carpet cleaners we looked at, one of them is probably the better choice for you. But, here’s the thing, while we only looked at one carpet cleaner from each brand, both of these brands have many different carpet cleaners that they offer, so if neither of those options works for you, you’ll still be able to find one, from either brand, that does work for you!

5 Recommended Carpet Cleaners
Best of the
Best For Tight Spaces Budget Pick
(< $100)
Portable Also
Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner Machine, 86T3 BISSELL Turboclean Powerbrush Pet Upright Carpet Cleaner Machine and Carpet Shampooer, 2085 Hoover PowerDash Pet Carpet Cleaner, FH50700 BISSELL SpotClean Pet Pro Portable Carpet Cleaner, 2458 Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner; Powerful, Portable Upright Deep Carpet Cleaning Machine
Bissell Bissell Hoover Bissell Rug Doctor
86T3 2085 FH50700 2458 93146
20.5 x 11 x 42.2 in 17.3 x 9.8 x 45 in 15.2 x 10.1 x 43.5 in 10 x 14 x 14 in 22.8 x 14.2 x 28 in
25 pounds 11 pounds 12.5 pounds 13.2 pounds 24 pounds